Conservative government says changes good for businesses, opposition says it’s bad for employees
The Ontario government passed sweeping labour reform legislation Wednesday, effectively rolling back many changes brought in by the previous Liberal regime.
The law freezes the province’s minimum wage at $14 an hour until 2020 and cuts two paid personal leave days for workers, among other things.
The governing Progressive Conservatives said the legislation would encourage job growth in the province. They have said the changes made by their predecessors imposed significant costs on businesses and argued the new legislation would ease that burden.
“It’s going to be good for employers, it’s going to be good for employees,” Tory House Leader Todd Smith said.
The measures were applauded by some in the business community but condemned by anti-poverty activists, union leaders and opposition parties, who say the changes will make life harder for average people.
“We just saw workers’ rights be torn out from under them, we just saw the lowest income workers lose $2,000 in increased pay because of the decisions that the government made today in passing legislation,” NDP Leader Andrea Horwath said.
Liberal legislator Nathalie Des Rosiers said the fact that Ontarians lost two paid sick days as a result of the legislation was “a real shame.”
“You need to ensure that your minimum standards of employment respond to the reality of work today,” she said, adding that was the purpose of the former Liberal government’s reforms.
The Tory government has said Premier Doug Ford received death threats and the labour minister had her constituency office vandalized after the legislation was introduced last month _ incidents that were denounced by all parties.
Labour and advocacy groups have raised the alarm at the short time frame allotted for consultation on the Tory legislation, with many saying they were denied the chance to weigh in.
Fight for $15 and Fairness, a group advocating for the minimum wage increase to be reinstated, said the five-hour limit placed on public input was in “stark contrast” with the 14 days of province-wide hearings the Liberals held on their labour changes.
“Let’s be clear, rich corporations are the only ones who stand to benefit from Bill 47, while the lowest wage earners will be forced back into poverty,” spokeswoman Pam Frache said of the law that passed Wednesday.
Ontario’s minimum wage increased from $11.60 to $14 an hour on Jan. 1, and was set to rise to $15 an hour next year as a result of the Liberals’ labour laws.
Under the government’s new legislation, it will remain at $14 until October 2020, with future increases tied to the rate of inflation.
To offset the move, the Tories have exempted those earning under $30,000 from provincial income tax and given a tax cut to those earning up to $38,000. But critics maintain the plan will save workers less money than they would gain through a wage hike.
The law will also bring the total of personal leave days down to eight from 10 — three for personal illness, two for bereavement leave and three for family responsibilities.
The legislation keeps provisions brought in by the Liberals that granted workers up to 10 days of leave if they or their child experiences domestic or sexual violence. It will also maintain regulations that grant Ontario workers three weeks of paid vacation after five years of service.
A number of scheduling provisions will be eliminated, however, including a minimum of three hours pay in the event a shift is cancelled 48 hours or less before it was scheduled to begin.
I applaud the Ontario government for increasing the basic exemption to $30,000 that alone will put approx $1000 of provincial income taxes back into the peoples hands, now if you can get the federal government to increase the federal basic exemption to $30,000 that would also put another $2500 into the peoples pockets.
It has always amazed me how some Governments can come up with ways to take our money and then dole it out back to us in the name of “benefits”, creating another level of bureaucracy for us to pay for (maybe that’s there job creation program).
Every time the minimum wage goes up, so does the amount of tax revenue go up and into government coffers (under current tax rules)
If governments, on both levels across this country, have agreed that the poverty line is at lets say $32,000, then why are they taxing ANY part of that?
Maybe what Pam Frache doesn’t get is that the so called “rich corporations” (and lets not forget that every SMALL business in this country is a “corporation” trying to survive) require PEOPLE to also spend money in order to survive themselves and as money is spent, taxes are collected on the profits. And as profits go up so do wages and employment. (quite the circle isn’t it)
That extra $3500 (almost $300 per month) in the hands of the people instead of the government could go a long way for anyone who is trying to make ends meet.
There are thousands of small business in this country trying to survive, and don’t get me wrong, minimum wage MUST follow inflation, however as wages go up under current tax rules, so does the governments take.
Again I applaud the Ontario government for increasing the provincial tax exemption to $30,000, and leaving money in the pockets of the people who earned it.
Governments continue to claim they are trying to help the “working poor” if that were true they would stop increasing their take. If the government didn’t have or need the money yesterday, why do they need it tomorrow?
Full disclosure: I am a retired small business owner from the province of Alberta.